Constructive Empiricism Without Underdetermination

Citation data:

Images of Empiricism: essays on science and stances, with a reply by Bas C. van Fraassen, Page: 11-33

Publication Year:
Usage 521
Downloads 521
Social Media 1
Tweets 1
Repository URL:
Van Dyck, Maarten
Oxford University Press
article description
According to a widely shared view, Bas van Fraassen is one of the main proponents of the argument from underdetermination. I argue that this opinion rests on a misreading of the Scientific Image. Van Fraassen’s use of the notion of empirical equivalence has been widely misunderstood. I offer a reconstruction of the main arguments for constructive empiricism, showing how the passages that have been taken to be part of an appeal to the argument from underdetermination should be interpreted. This has obvious implications for the discussions concerning scientific realism.