Historical Reconstruction: Gaining Epistemic Access to the Deep Past

Citation data:

Philosophy and Theory in Biology, ISSN: 1949-0739, Vol: 3, Issue: 20170609, Page: 1-19

Publication Year:
Usage 154
Downloads 154
Captures 28
Readers 28
Social Media 2
Tweets 1
Shares, Likes & Comments 1
Citations 9
Citation Indexes 9
Repository URL:
Forber, Patrick; Griffith, Eric
University of Michigan Library; Michigan Publishing, University of Michigan Library
article description
We discuss the scientific task of historical reconstruction and the problem of epistemic access. We argue that strong epistemic support for historical claims consists in the consilience of multiple independent lines of evidence, and analyze the impact hypothesis for the End-Cretaceous mass extinction to illustrate the accrual of epistemic support. Although there are elements of the impact hypothesis that enjoy strong epistemic support, the general conditions for this are strict, and help to clarify the difficulties associated with reconstructing the deep past.