Mystery and the evidential impact of unexplainables

Publication Year:
Usage 173
Downloads 173
Social Media 3
Tweets 3
Repository URL:
Colombo, Matteo; Klein, Dominik
Most Recent Tweet View All Tweets
preprint description
What’s the evidential impact of learning that something is a mystery? To answer this question, we first explicate the notion of a mystery in terms of unexplainability. After distinguishing different ways in which something can be unexplainable, we develop a test to evaluate the evidential impact of two distinct types of unexplainables: symmetrical and asymmetrical unexplainables. We argue that only a-symmetrical unexplainables have evidential impact. We finally clarify how our explication of mysteries as unexplainables complements existing accounts of abduction and contributes to the literature on the mystery of consciousness.