Old Evidence in the Development of Quantum Theory
- Publication Year:
- Usage 124
- Downloads 124
- PhilSci-Archive 124
- Repository URL:
- Most Recent Tweet View All Tweets
In this paper, I evaluate Hartmann & Fitelson’s solution to the Bayesian problem of old evidence by applying it to an early stage in the development of quantum theory. I argue that this case study suggests that whether old evidence is anomalous or not affects its support for a hypothesis. I introduce and defend two formal assumptions to accommodate this idea. This analysis not only explicates an important historical example, but it also shows that the given solution captures the intuitive importance of “surprising” evidence that has previously been problematic in the context of old evidence.