Kuhnian theory-choice and virtue convergence: facing the base rate fallacy

Publication Year:
Usage 75
Downloads 75
Social Media 1
Tweets 1
Repository URL:
Schindler, Samuel
Most Recent Tweet View All Tweets
preprint description
Perhaps the strongest argument for scientific realism, the no-miracles-argument, has been said to commit the so-called base rate fallacy. The apparent elusiveness of the base rate of true theories has even been said to undermine the rationality of the entire realism debate. In this paper, I confront this challenge by arguing, on the basis of the Kuhnian picture of theory choice, that a theory is likely to be true if it possesses multiple theoretical virtues and is embraced by numerous scientists, even when the base rate converges to zero.