Sustaining a Rational Disagreement

Publication Year:
Usage 1633
Downloads 1633
Repository URL:
Kelp, Christoph; Douven, Igor
conference paper description
Much recent discussion in social epistemology has focussed on the question of whether peers can rationally sustain a disagreement. A growing number of social epistemologists hold that the answer is negative. We point to considerations from the history of science that favor rather the opposite answer. However, we also explain how the other position can appear intuitively attractive.