Smokers and psychos: Egan cases don't work

Publication Year:
Usage 369
Downloads 369
Repository URL:
Ahmed, Arif
preprint description
Andy Egan's Smoking Lesion and Psycho Button cases are supposed to be counterexamples to Causal Decision Theory (CDT). I argue that if well-known Newcomb type cases don't already refute CDT then neither do Egan's cases. In any event Egan's cases add nothing new to whatever case already exists against CDT.