Against the Statistical Account of Special Science Laws

Publication Year:
Usage 347
Downloads 347
Social Media 3
Tweets 3
Repository URL:
Hüttemann, Andreas; Reutlinger, Alexander
preprint description
John Earman and John T. Roberts advocate a challenging and radical claim regarding the semantics of laws in the special sciences: the statistical account. According to this account, a typical special science law “asserts a certain precisely defined statistical relation among well-defined variables” (Earman and Roberts 1999) and this statistical relation does not require being hedged by ceteris paribus conditions. In this paper, we raise two objections against the attempt to cash out the content of special science generalizations in statistical terms.