Reply to Lewis: metaphysics versus epistemology

Publication Year:
Usage 579
Downloads 579
Repository URL:
Papineau, David; Durà-Vilà, Víctor
preprint description
Peter J. Lewis argued that the Everettian interpretation of quantum mechanics implies the unpopular halfer position in the Sleeping Beauty debate. We retorted that it is perfectly coherent to be an Everettian and an ordinary thirder. In a recent reply to our paper Lewis further clarifies the basis for his thinking. We think this brings out nicely where he goes wrong: he underestimates the importance of metaphysical considerations in determining rational credences.