A single narrative : obscuring difference in the Guardian campaign against female genital cutting

Publication Year:
2015
Usage 63
Downloads 45
Abstract Views 18
Repository URL:
https://arminda.whitman.edu/theses/247
Author(s):
Donahue, Alyssa Mary Finlay
Tags:
Sanjay Seth (1961- ); Female circumcision --Female genital cutting (FGC) -- Political aspects; Liberalism -- Philosophy; Intolerance -- Liberalism; Narratives -- Single Narrative; Guardian Newspapers Ltd -- “End Female Genitalia Mutilation Global Media Campaign”; Western countries -- Westernization; Whitman College -- Dissertation collection 2016 -- Rhetoric Studies; Rhetoric
thesis / dissertation description
Female genital cutting (FGC) has become an incontestable atrocity in Western public discourse. Many argue that popular Western advocacy against the practice tends to denigrate FGC cultures and to reduce genitally cut women to voiceless victims. In 2014, British newspaper the Guardian joined the fight against FGC with the launch of its “End Female Genital Mutilation Global Media Campaign.” Drawing on postcolonial criticism and political scientist Sanjay Seth’s theory of liberalism’s intolerance of difference, this thesis argues that the Guardian campaign authorizes only one condemning narrative of FGC that obscures all others. Through this single narrative model, the campaign usurps the agency of the same women it seeks to liberate.