Does Gender Raise the Ethical Bar? Exploring the Punishment of Ethical Violations at Work

Citation data:

SSRN Electronic Journal

Publication Year:
2016
Usage 1747
Abstract Views 1409
Downloads 338
Captures 14
Readers 14
Social Media 2
Tweets 2
Ratings
SSRN
SSRN Id:
2770012
DOI:
10.2139/ssrn.2770012
Author(s):
Kennedy, Jessica A.; McDonnell, Mary-Hunter ; Stephens, Nicole M.
Publisher(s):
Elsevier BV
Tags:
Gender; Ethical Violations; Punishment; Stereotypes
Most Recent Tweet View All Tweets
article description
We investigate whether women are targets of more severe punishment than men following ethical violations at work. Using an experimental design, Study 1 finds evidence that ethical behavior is more strongly prescribed for women than for men, even when they occupy an identical professional role. Study 2 manipulates the gender of a manager in a hypothetical scenario and finds that women are punished more severely than men for ethical violations at work. It also tests the scope of our theory by asking whether women are punished more for errors in general, or only for intentional ethical violations. Using field data, Study 3 examines how severely attorneys are punished for violating the American Bar Association’s ethical rules. Female attorneys are punished more severely than male attorneys, after accounting for a variety of factors. Greater representation of women among decision-makers diminishes the gender disparity in punishment. Our research documents a new prescriptive stereotype faced by women and helps to explain the persistence of gender disparities in organizations. It highlights punishment severity as a novel mechanism by which institutions may derail women’s careers more than men’s.