Biological Nitrification Inhibitors with Antagonistic and Synergistic Effects on Growth of Ammonia Oxidisers and Soil Nitrification

Biological nitrification inhibition (BNI) refers to the plant-mediated process in which nitrification is inhibited through rhizospheric release of diverse metabolites. While it has been assumed that interactive effects of these metabolites shape rhizosphere processes, including BNI, there is scant evidence supporting this claim. Hence, it was a primary objective to assess the interactive effects of selected metabolites, including caffeic acid (CA), vanillic acid (VA), vanillin (VAN), syringic acid (SA), and phenylalanine (PHE), applied as single and combined compounds, against pure cultures of various ammonia-oxidising bacteria (AOB, Nitrosomonas europaea, Nitrosospira multiformis, Nitrosospira tenuis, Nitrosospira briensis) and archaea (AOA, Nitrososphaera viennensis), as well as soil nitrification. Additionally, benzoic acid (BA) was examined as a novel biological nitrification inhibitor. All metabolites, except SA, tested as single compounds, achieved varied levels of inhibition of microbial growth, with CA exhibiting the highest inhibitory potential. Similarly, all metabolites applied as single compounds, except PHE, inhibited soil nitrification by up to 62%, with BA being the most potent. Inhibition of tested nitrifying microbes was also observed when compounds were assessed in combination. The combinations VA + PH, VA + CA, and VA + VAN exhibited synergism against N. tenuis and N. briensis, while others showed antagonism against N. europaea, N. multiformis, and N. viennensis. Although all combinations suppressed soil nitrification, their interactions against soil nitrification revealed antagonism. Our findings indicate that both antagonism and synergism are possible in rhizospheric interactions involving BNI metabolites, resulting in growth inhibition of nitrifiers and suppression of soil nitrification.