Is tadpole coloration adaptive against bird predation?

Birds are visually oriented predators, and some are known or supposed to prey upon tadpoles. Neotropical tadpoles exhibit several colorations that could potentially improve survivorship through camouflage, aposematism, or mimetism. In this study, we tested tadpoles of two hylid species for protective effects of their colorations, one potentially aposematic (Bokermannohyla martinsi) and another (Ololygon machadoi) previously hypothesized as disruptive and/or mimetic to a naucorid insect (Limnocoris porphyros). We conducted in situ and ex situ experiments and observed that the uniformly black B. martinsi tadpoles were more intensely preyed upon by birds than those of O. machadoi, regardless of background color, which may have happened because the disruptive coloration of O. machadoi hampered its detection. Alternatively, the duration of the experiments may have been too short for birds to learn about a possible toxicity of B. martinsi tadpoles, which are more active and thus more visible. Birds that had a previous experience with L. porphyros tended to attack tadpoles of O. machadoi less than naive birds. On the other hand, we did not observe any change in predation levels upon B. martinsi tadpoles whether presented to birds before or after L. porphyros. Our results indicate that the predation by birds, although apparently occasional, is likely to be influenced by tadpole coloration.